I really dropped the ball and never updated weather I liked the swamp witch tires or not. So far they have been great. Ride smoother than my rawhides did. Tear through the snow and get great grip on even glare ice. They DO swim, just NOT very fast at all. Slower than the rawhide IIIs did even. But that's why I have an outboard motor. Havent got any real mud tests yet, but if its anything like the snow, they are a great tire.